<<< back to article list

Cottages for Sale in the Muskoka Area | Over $500,000


  • +1

Blog by John & Bonnie Fincham, Brokers | August 31st, 2017


There's just over 250 cottages for sale in the Muskoka region that are priced over $ 500,000. Here's a list of the properties which include land, waterfront lots, year round homes and cottages.

MLS Number

Address

Waterfront Name

List Price

521550015

CRIPPLE CREEK  LOGGING RD E                                   

MORGAN

$1,850,000.00

496600000503703         

672 TILLICUM BAY RD

NIPISSING

$859,000.00

481960231

86 TONDERN ISLAND

MUSKOKA

$4,995,000.00

481000002

ISLAND 2 FAIRVIEW ISLAND

LAKE OF BAYS                                  

$3,998,000.00

480640634

1183 ECHO BAY RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$949,000.00

481560185A

1014 PLEASANT VIEW POINT RD

MUSKOKA

$3,995,000.00

491880354

49 TRAILS END RD

NOSBONSING

$1,550,000.00

491880354A

49 TRAILS END RD

NOSBONSING

$1,550,000.00

522180225

836 LAKE NIPISSING RD

SOUTH

$699,000.00

522180225A

836 LAKE NIPISSING RD

SOUTH

$699,000.00

522160240

261 GREEN ACRES RD

WOLFE

$1,300,000.00

521360297

1732 PEGGS MOUNTAIN RD S

BIG DOE

$849,000.00

520540486

227 HAWTHORNE DR

EAGLE

$574,900.00

521940423

72 LOOKOUT POINT RD

JOSEPH

$3,995,000.00

1608708

343 FIRESIDE LODGE RD. RD

LITTLE VERMILION

$2,900,000.00

481590352

1022 MILFORD MANOR RD

MUSKOKA

$4,449,000.00

1704039

1022 MILFORD MANOR RD # 2

MUSKOKA

$1,249,000.00

1704040

1022 MILFORD MANOR RD # 2

MUSKOKA

$3,495,000.00

1614932

2 FAIRVIEW ISL

LAKE OF BAYS

$3,998,000.00

521360297A

1732 PEGGS MOUNTAIN RD S

BIG DOE

$849,000.00

481590157

2867 MUSKOKA ROAD 118W # 15

MUSKOKA

$2,495,000.00

481420051

1118 NORTH DR

BRUCE

$2,599,000.00

1623251

1041 HILLTOP

LAKE OF BAYS

$9,790,000.00

421250835

420 BIG STONE BAY RD

LAKE OF THE WOODS

$1,950,000.00

481030863

3497 BRUNEL RD # 16

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,795,000.00

481030863A

3497 BRUNEL RD # 16

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,795,000.00

521500046

1224 GRASS LAKE RD

GRASS

$729,000.00

481380241

1347 ROSSEAU LAKE ROAD 1 # 16

ROSSEAU

$6,925,900.00

521890407

360 HEALEY LAKE WATER ACCESS

HEALEY

$924,900.00

480620747

1462 OLD HIGHWAY 117

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,850,000.00

521340424

1444 NIPISSING RD RD S

AHMIC

$549,900.00

481530108

1179 CAMP JACKSON RD # 5

MOON

$549,000.00

522230010

CAMPBELL`S BAY RD

NIPISSING

$1,499,000.00

480990002

ISLAND

FAIRY

$999,000.00

521930220

217 HAMER BAY RD

STINSON

$3,999,000.00

480991654

58 ROE RD

FAIRY

$3,990,000.00

481550731

1007 WALKER LANE

MUSKOKA

$789,000.00

1626249

295 60 HIGH

FAIRY LAKE

$2,100,000.00

521950152

51 PEACOCK RD # LAKE

ROSSEAU

$2,999,999.00

1627289

1707 & 1711 PEGGS MOUNTAIN RD

DOE

$539,000.00

480640573

FOX POINT RD

OXTONGUE

$1,200,000.00

481730244

1070 RUSTY ROCK RD

MUSKOKA

$3,895,000.00

481920258

1130 BAY ST E

MUSKOKA

$589,000.00

481730254

1476 STEPHEN`S BAY RD

MUSKOKA

$4,495,000.00

480640114

1189 RONVILLE RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$699,000.00

521800418

41 SUNNY POINT RD

OTTER

$4,500,000.00

1624336

LOT 5 CLAREN CRES

VERNON

$649,000.00

481420036

HIGHWAY 169

JOSEPH

$650,000.00

1700778

LOTS 28, 30 & 31 11 CON

BIG STEPHEN & SAGE

$575,000.00

480640788

4243 MUSKOKA ROAD 117 RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,960,000.00

522000213

155 BURGESS RD

ROSSEAU

$14,950,000.00

481730244A

1070 RUSTY ROCK RD

MUSKOKA

$3,895,000.00

1701092

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 1A

MUSKOKA

$799,000.00

521940381

16 SYKES RD

JOSEPH

$3,725,000.00

481560073

1023 HEATHER LODGE RD

MUSKOKA

$3,795,000.00

480650666

1170 PORT CUNNINGTON RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$945,000.00

480650771

1170 PORT CUNNINGTON RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,600,000.00

481680043

227 SANTA`S VILLAGE RD

MUSKOKA

$749,000.00

391170252

1170 VISTA ROAD RD N

KAWAGAMA

$1,450,000.00

393060147

1054 DALMATION

LIVINGSTONE

$575,000.00

1623705

LOT 11 CLAREN CRES

VERNON

$795,000.00

1623601

LOT 7 CLAREN CRES

VERNON

$675,000.00

521100151

51 GREAT NORTH RD

GEORGIAN BAY

$5,000,000.00

1703223

106 TONDERN ISLAND RD

LAKE MUSKOKA

$3,450,000.00

522340379

180 WRIGHT POINT ROAD

WILSON

$899,000.00

522340475

EDWARDS ISLAND

WILSON

$749,999.00

521960208

305 HIGHWY 632

ROSSEAU

$929,000.00

481480320

1020 CEDAR RAIL DR # 1

ROSSEAU

$949,000.00

480970238

730 ASPDIN RD

VERNON

$599,000.00

480970249

157 LIGHTHOUSE POINT RD

VERNON

$699,000.00

13244560

157 LIGHTHOUSE POINT AND 730 ASPDIN RD

VERNON

$1,298,000.00

1703664

RICHARDSON ISLAND

NIPISSING

$1,485,000.00

481750633

1349 NARROWS RD

MUSKOKA

$3,395,000.00

481450147

1002 MURPHY RD

LAKE JOESPH

$5,900,000.00

481250777

LOT 2 CLAREN CRES

VERNON

$2,890,000.00

481250777A

LOT 2 CLAREN CRES

VERNON

$2,890,000.00

480640066

1587 T/W 1585 SEABREEZE RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$4,950,000.00

522160134

105 SUNRISE DR

RUTH

$899,000.00

481530171

1160 CRANBERRY RD

MEDORA

$3,250,000.00

521970541

309 HIGHWAY 141 RD

BIG WHITEFISH

$595,000.00

481430096

2581 PENINSULA RD # 3

LITTLE  JOSEPH

$6,690,000.00

480630812

544 BIGWIN ISL

LAKE OF BAYS

$589,000.00

481580227

1090 EILEAN GOWAN ISL

MUSKOKA

$638,000.00

481330548

1137 OLD PARRY SOUND RD S

NUTT

$25,000,000.00

481470697

1256 HEMLOCK POINT RD

JOSEPH

$8,939,000.00

1704529A

HORN LAKE

HORN

$579,999.00

481250058

124 HOODSTOWN SHORES RD

VERNON

$1,299,000.00

1627755

1093A OAK RD

KAHSHE

$1,449,000.00

1704529

HORN LAKE NE

HORN

$579,999.00

480610918

1114 MAIN ST

LAKE OF BAYS

$839,000.00

480991642

39 EUROPE LANE

FAIRY

$2,950,000.00

521000222

7 PARTRIDGE BAY

GEORGIAN BAY

$675,000.00

521020066

1 SOUNDVIEW CRT

GEORGIAN BAY

$2,200,000.00

521940490

364  LOT A STANLEY HOUSE RD

JOSEPH

$1,300,000.00

521940491

364 STANLEY HOUSE       LOT B RD

JOSEPH

$1,295,000.00

481460333

1076 BASS LAKE RD # 4

BASS

$630,000.00

481960255

7 PINE ISLAND # M81

MUSKOKA

$1,849,000.00

480330679

1152 BRADLEY RD # 18

MUSKOKA

$1,195,000.00

481460659

1057 HAMILLS POINT RD

JOSEPH

$2,395,000.00

520840368

5331 HIGHWAY 124

AHMIC

$549,000.00

1623621

5333 HIGHWAY 124

AHMIC

$1,249,000.00

480620529

1378 OLD HIGHWAY 117

LAKE OF BAYS

$619,900.00

521940024

22 PLAYFAIR ISLAND

JOSEPH

$2,390,000.00

1705629

LOT 6 CLAREN CRES

VERNON

$695,000.00

1705637

LOT 8 CLAREN CRES

VERNON

$675,000.00

481590123

1121 SCARCLIFFE RD # 47

MUSKOKA

$1,975,000.00

480640650

1114 JOSEPH TAPLEY TRAIL

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,850,000.00

521280276

10 FIRE ROUTE 161

MANITOUWABING

$999,900.00

480560533

1010 LAMBERT RD

BLACK

$780,000.00

521300231

146 BLACKWATER LAKE RD

BLACKWATER

$589,000.00

480560533A

1010 LAMBERT RD

BLACK

$780,000.00

481550533

1167 ACTON ISLAND RD

MUSKOKA

$4,995,000.00

521490502

571 ISLAND LAKE RD

LITTLE BLUE

$995,000.00

1706122

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 1B

MUSKOKA

$799,000.00

1706127

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 4A

MUSKOKA

$799,000.00

1706131

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 6A

MUSKOKA

$799,000.00

1706133

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 6B

MUSKOKA

$799,000.00

1706136

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 7A

MUSKOKA

$799,000.00

1706137

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 7B

MUSKOKA

$799,000.00

1706147

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 2A

MUSKOKA

$549,000.00

1706149

1841 MUSKOKA RD 118 W # 2C

MUSKOKA

$549,000.00

481590181

2795 MUSKOKA ROAD 118W RD # 3

MUSKOKA

$3,445,500.00

480660095

1050 PENMORE LANE

PENINSULA

$985,000.00

522160381

1945B ALSACE RD N

RUTH LAKE

$639,900.00

521820950

40B ALICE LANE

OTTER

$995,000.00

488430012

1119 ELGIN HOUSE RD # 12

JOSEPH

$1,029,000.00

481770143

1023 BIRCH POINT RD

MUSKOKA

$1,259,000.00

1606133

97 JOSEPH ST # BH 3

INDIAN

$995,000.00

1606118

97 JOSEPH ST # BH 2

INDIAN

$995,000.00

520800547

58  CHAPMAN  DR W

CECEBE

$995,000.00

481750633A

1349 NARROWS RD

MUSKOKA

$3,395,000.00

480650668

1151 PORT CUNNINGTON RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$645,000.00

480620367

1093 GLENMOUNT RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$659,000.00

521860390

DOUBLE ISLAND GEORGIAN BAY

GEORGIAN BAY

$1,485,000.00

521010650A

11 SAWDUST BAY RD N

GEORGIAN BAY

$2,395,000.00

521930902

31 HIGH POINT DR

JOSEPH

$8,500,000.00

521510091

3758 HIGHWAY 518 E

SAND

$1,195,777.00

480620800

TROUT LAKE RD

TROUT

$1,100,000.00

481470469

1093 HEMLOCK POINT SIDEROAD

JOSEPH

$2,995,000.00

481470473

1112 HEMLOCK POINT SIDE RD

JOSEPH

$6,850,000.00

480320149

1030 BROADLEY RD # 6A&B

MUSKOKA

$4,995,000.00

480320211

1030 BROADLEY RD # 6C

MUSKOKA

$1,949,000.00

521230106

13 OLD MAPLE TRAIL

NINE MILE

$949,000.00

481500786

1093 ISLAND PARK RD

INDIAN RIVER

$1,650,000.00

520550018

172 ANGUS POINT RD

EAGLE

$765,000.00

481230076

186 CAMP NEWPORT RD

SKELETON

$848,000.00

521930382

223 HAMER BAY RD # A

JOSEPH

$4,799,000.00

521810105

31 BRUCES TRAIL

OTTER

$949,000.00

481430328

483 LAKE JOSEPH

JOSEPH

$1,695,000.00

1708032

1003 FOX RUN

MUSKOKA

$1,185,000.00

481500771

98 JOSEPH ST

INDIAN RIVER/LAKE MUSKOKA

$895,000.00

481460262

1197 HAMILLS POINT RD

JOSEPH

$1,375,000.00

481470283

4182 MUSKOKA RD 169 # 34

JOSEPH

$8,995,000.00

481030471

1299 BURLMARIE RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,999,000.00

481390524

1683 BRACKENRIG RD

ROSSEAU

$2,895,000.00

481960278

12 BUCK ISLAND

MUSKOKA

$3,395,000.00

481720426

1074 BEAUMONT FARM RD

MUSKOKA

$880,000.00

521940279

26 HIGH HILL RD

JOSEPH

$3,275,000.00

480220088

3 SR406

SEVERN

$1,050,000.00

521230405

1 WINDY LANE FR#116

PORTAGE

$545,000.00

520550025

139 ANGUS POINT RD

EAGLE

$549,900.00

481340249

1018-1 COVE RD

THREE MILE

$549,900.00

481080079

1109 PETER RD

HEALEY

$579,000.00

481340249A

1018-1 COVE RD

THREE MILE

$549,900.00

480310232

10 SHAW ISLAND

MUSKOKA

$695,000.00

521000242

68 CONSERVATION DR

GEORGIAN BAY

$699,000.00

1709203

1034 VIEW POINT TRAIL

MUSKOKA

$3,995,995.00

480610065

23189 HIGHWAY 35

LAKE OF BAYS

$999,900.00

480610065A

23189 HIGHWAY 35

LAKE OF BAYS

$999,900.00

521040043

9 FELSMAN LANE

GEORGIAN BAY

$3,995,000.00

481590301

1032 TOM WROE RD

MUSKOKA

$5,495,000.00

481720163

1594 &1588 BROWNING ISLAND

MUSKOKA

$1,350,000.00

521850731

85 SANDY ISLAND

GEORGIAN BAY

$799,000.00

481540389

KETURA ISLAND

MUSKOKA

$995,000.00

481540144

1246 DUDLEY RD # 1

MUSKOKA

$1,195,000.00

481470562

1153 ROBERTS BAY RD # 12

JOSEPH

$6,397,989.00

521800625

10 LEN JOHNSON LANE

HORSESHOE

$1,495,000.00

1627755A

1093A OAK RD

KAHSHE

$1,449,000.00

481470319

1101 ELGIN HOUSE RD

JOSEPH

$4,499,000.00

481440356

EAGLE ISLAND

JOSEPH

$6,888,000.00

1709988

EAGLE ISLAND

JOSEPH

$11,998,888.00

521990413

155 HIGHWAY 632

ROSSEAU

$989,900.00

521800620

10 LEN JOHNSON LANE

HORSESHOE

$949,000.00

488430003

1126 ELGIN HOUSE RD # 2

JOSEPH

$869,000.00

521340075

161 WIND ROSE LANE

CECEBE

$1,195,000.00

480440085

690 KAHSHE LAKE

KAHSHE

$699,000.00

481720426A

1074 BEAUMONT FARM RD

MUSKOKA

$880,000.00

480460047

1033 FIRE ROUTE 6B

RILEY

$649,900.00

1710434

AKOMAK

AHMIC

$1,490,000.00

480330136

1052 MCKENZIE RD

MUSKOKA

$665,000.00

480460047A

1033 FIRE ROUTE 6B

RILEY

$649,900.00

491890177

112 MALLARD HAVEN RD

WISTIWASING

$849,900.00

481400231

1038 EL-KEE POINT LANE

BRANDY

$899,000.00

481780086

1615 MUSKOKA RD N

MUSKOKA

$4,500,000.00

480630293

1385 PORT CUNNINGTON RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$1,150,000.00

481250301

185 SOUTH DR

VERNON

$649,000.00

480550596

1098 PINE LAKE SHORES PVT RD

PINE

$599,900.00

1710878

40 LOWER FRY`S LAKE RD

DUBE

$789,000.00

521821125

129 OTTER LAKE RD

OTTER

$529,900.00

480650668A

1151 PORT CUNNINGTON RD

LAKE OF BAYS

$645,000.00

481480007

1805 PENINSULA RD N # 186

JOSEPH

$1,850,000.00

481540111

1559 MOON RIVER RD

MOON

$699,900.00

480660544

1103 WOLF BAY RD

PENINSULA

$749,900.00

521940474

1868 LAKE JOSEPH RD

JOSEPH

$535,000.00

481720476A

20 STANLEY ISLAND

MUSKOKA

$1,095,000.00

481720476

20 STANLEY ISLAND

MUSKOKA

$1,095,000.00

521280899

17 FIRE ROUTE 152A

MANITOUWABING

$599,900.00

521930733

45 TRAILS END

JOSEPH

$5,450,000.00

480440149

<span face="Helvetica" color="#000000%2